Local tips on New York steakhouses

If you want an authentic NYC steakhouse night, skip the obvious tourist spots at first and try to hit places on weekdays. Ever been to Keens? Their pipe-smoking ambiance makes you feel like you stepped back to old New York, plus their mutton chop is legendary. Another tip: split the steak and order a handful of sides to taste more flavors. Also, late winter is a surprisingly calm time to visit, so you might actually snag a prime table without reservations. For something different, give the flat iron steak at St. Anselm a try , many locals swear by it for being flavorful without breaking the bank.

Oh, and bring cash or have your card ready because some places demand quick payment and may not accept all cards. It’s old school, but that’s part of New York’s charm.

Frequently Asked Questions

Got questions about steakhouses in New York? Here’s the local scoop.

Usually, yes. Places like Peter Luger get packed fast, especially on weekends, so booking ahead is your best bet. But some spots, like St. Anselm or Keens, can sometimes squeeze you in on a weeknight without one.
If you want a classic experience, you can’t go wrong with a porterhouse or ribeye. The porterhouse is a staple at New York’s old-school places. But if you’re feeling adventurous, ask about the hanger steak or flat iron, which often have more flavor and cost less.
Definitely. Brooklyn has been killing it with steakhouses lately. Peter Luger is the poster child, but places like St. Anselm or Dinosaur Bar-B-Que (which blends BBQ and steak) add a flavorful spin beyond Manhattan’s scene.
Tipping in New York usually hovers around 20% if service is good. Steakhouses tend to be a bit more formal, so don’t skimp unless you want to stand out – and not in a good way.
Absolutely! Don’t just focus on the steak. Classic creamed spinach, crispy onion rings, and loaded baked potatoes are often the unsung heroes here. Oh, and many places have a damn good whiskey or cocktail menu that pairs nicely.
It varies. Some are old-school wood-paneled joints with a clubby feel, and others are more casual or industrial-chic. Keens feels historic, while St. Anselm has a laid-back, hip vibe. Depends on what mood you’re in.

Top Things To Do in New York

See All →

We Are Part of the My Guide Network!

My Guide New York is part of the global My Guide Network of Online & Mobile travel guides. We are now in 180+ Destinations and Growing.

Nearby Destinations

Add to your trip

Add your travel dates so we can place this on the right day, or save it for later.