Not quite what you’re looking for yet?

Use filters to narrow things down or explore other categories.


Quick tips on eating Italian in New York

If you want to eat Italian in New York like a local, skip the obvious tourist traps and head for neighborhoods where actual Italians live or used to live. Little Italy in Manhattan is small now, so check out Arthur Avenue in the Bronx for a more authentic vibe.

Also, don’t be afraid to try a no-frills bakery or deli. Places like Faicco’s in the West Village have incredible cured meats and sandwiches that usually fly under the radar. And if you’re in Brooklyn, try a pie from Lucali or Roberta’s,they’re worth the wait. Pro tip: go early or late to avoid long lines, especially on weekends.

Frequently Asked Questions

Got questions about Italian food in New York? Here’s some friendly advice.

You can’t talk Italian in New York without mentioning pizza. Joe’s Pizza in Greenwich Village is a classic go-to, perfect if you want a quick, thin-crust slice. For a sit-down, try Lucali in Brooklyn,it’s a bit pricier but the dough and fresh toppings are unreal.
Absolutely. Little Italy’s great for that tourist vibe, but for authentic Italian food, check out the East Village or even the Bronx’s Arthur Avenue. Those neighborhoods have family-run places serving traditional dishes without the crowds.
Totally. Arthur Avenue is the real-deal Italian market and restaurant scene that most people miss. It’s like stepping into a different era with old-school bakeries and butchers. The food’s just as good, if not better, than anything in Manhattan.
You won’t struggle. Most Italian places offer decent veggie dishes since pasta and veggies go hand in hand. I recommend L’Artusi or Il Buco,both have creative vegetable-based dishes that even meat-eaters love.
Definitely say yes. Cannoli and tiramisu are standards, but some places like Veniero’s in the East Village have Italian pastries that are basically works of art. If you get a chance, try their cheesecake or their fresh ricotta treats.

Top Things To Do in New York

See All →

We Are Part of the My Guide Network!

My Guide New York is part of the global My Guide Network of Online & Mobile travel guides. We are now in 180+ Destinations and Growing.

Nearby Destinations

Add to your trip

Add your travel dates so we can place this on the right day, or save it for later.