72ND Eatery

New York



At a glance

Features
Alfresco Dining
Price
Moderately Priced
Local tip
Try the sandwich selection for a mix of classic and bold flavors.

72nd Eatery, located on Columbus Avenue in New York, offers a diverse array of casual yet flavorful dining options tailored to a variety of tastes. Known for its inviting atmosphere, the venue focuses heavily on delivering a satisfying experience whether guests are stopping by for a quick bite or a more leisurely meal. From renowned pizzas to a multitude of sandwiches, the menu caters to those who enjoy classic and contemporary options. Pizza enthusiasts can indulge in personal pies or slices, while the sandwich selection includes a blend of traditional American classics and eclectic international flavors.

The eatery's extensive menu features options ranging from Italian dishes like Chicken Parmigiana to select offerings for vegetarians. There is a marked emphasis on freshness and quality, evident in the selection of meats and vegetables. Pita sandwiches are also available, providing a lighter choice for those keeping an eye on their caloric intake. Sandwiches like the Italian Club or Chicken Milano showcase the diversity of flavors with ingredients such as Genoa salami, fresh mozzarella, and various dressings that add zest and character to each dish.

With flexible operating hours from early morning through to the evening, 72nd Eatery is a fitting choice for any meal of the day. Its ideal location makes it convenient for locals and visitors alike, with easy accessibility in a vibrant New York neighborhood. Beyond the food, the atmosphere is conducive to casual dining experiences, making it suitable for families, groups, or solo diners wanting to enjoy a hearty meal amid the bustling yet welcoming vibe of an urban setting.

72nd Eatery champions a straightforward approach to its business model, focusing on ensuring a seamless order and dining experience without unnecessary complexities or excessive costs. While the menu is suitable for various dietary preferences, its core strength lies in offering dependable, flavorful dishes that appeal to both traditional and modern palates.

Reviews

J G J G Aug 2026

Perfect NYC bodega. Fast, delicious, delightful. Bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll with a cafe con leche.

Robert Sanchez Robert Sanchez Jun 2026

Great food. Service was pretty good too. Good people

james amster james amster Dec 2025

This great fast casual spot features the BEST rotisserie chicken. They also have great smoothies and nice desserts. Extremely warm customer service (shoutout to Johnny). They have self serve drinks. I haven’t tried the pizza but it looks good. Can’t wait to have the chicken again

Jonte Myers Jonte Myers Oct 2025

Stopped in for a meal and was pleasantly surprised by how much this place offers. It’s conveniently located with a warm, relaxed atmosphere and friendly, attentive service. The menu has something for everyone, fresh pizzas, burgers, rotisserie chicken, salads, sandwiches, and a full bakery and coffee corner. Prices are very affordable, a solid, satisfying meal runs around sixteen dollars plus tax, which makes it an easy choice for a casual lunch or dinner. Generous portions, great quality, and a cozy vibe make this a spot I’d definitely visit again.

Read all reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions

72nd Eatery specializes in a diverse selection of pizzas, sandwiches, and casual American dishes with international influences.
72nd Eatery is located at 261 Columbus Avenue, New York, NY, 10023.
Yes, 72nd Eatery has several vegetarian options available on their menu.
Yes, 72nd Eatery is suitable for families and groups, offering a relaxed atmosphere and diverse menu options.
72nd Eatery is open from 7:00 AM to 10:30 PM.
Yes, the menu at 72nd Eatery offers items that can cater to various dietary restrictions.
The details about reservations are not specified, so it's advisable to contact the venue directly.
The availability of outdoor seating is not mentioned, so contacting the venue for the most accurate information is recommended.
Ordering can be done via the app preferred by the venue, offering a convenient and cost-effective option.
The sandwich selection offers a wide range of flavors, making it a popular choice to try.

Top Things To Do in New York

See All →

We Are Part of the My Guide Network!

My Guide New York is part of the global My Guide Network of Online & Mobile travel guides. We are now in 180+ Destinations and Growing.

Nearby Destinations

Add to your trip

Add your travel dates so we can place this on the right day, or save it for later.