Dive 75
New York
Reviews
"We had an incredible time watching the game here. The atmosphere is high-energy and perfect for hanging out with a group. The classic cheeseburger and sweet potato fries were delicious and served piping hot. The bartenders were fast and very friendly."
Dive 75 is one of those places that just feels easy the second you walk in. It has been part of the Upper West Side since the late 90s, and it still has that true neighborhood bar energy where people actually hang out instead of just passing through. The name comes from scuba diving, which is a big passion of the owner, and you will notice subtle nods to that, including the fish tanks that give the place a little personality without feeling over the top. The vibe is what really makes it. There are couches, board games, and enough space to actually settle in. You will see people deep into a game of Connect Four or just hanging out and talking like it is their living room. It is social without being loud or chaotic. You can walk in with a group or show up solo and feel comfortable either way. The drinks are better than you would expect from something calling itself a dive. Great beer selection, solid whiskey choices, and prices that make it very easy to stay for another round. And one of the best parts is the BYOF setup. You can bring your own food, grab takeout from nearby, or even bring something from home. It makes the whole night feel flexible and personal, like you are building your own perfect bar experience. What really stands out is how natural it all feels. Nothing is trying too hard. It is just a relaxed, welcoming spot that people keep coming back to because it feels like theirs. The kind of bar you do not plan your night around, but somehow always end up at anyway.
Good drinks but they are abusing their fish. When I asked the bartender about the fish’s health he said that there was a “fish guy” that has been in rehab for weeks so they don’t know what’s going on. That should not be an excuse for abusing a poor little soul. Someone please hold this “fish guy” accountable. Little edit in response the owner's response: Hey! Thanks for your reply. I don't think there was much of a misunderstanding with your bartender. He literally word for word said "He's been in rehab for forever" and no follow up. Before attacking someone decades younger than you online maybe train your employees to be able to give me your spiel on your fish guy––whom I send my condolences to. If I had known his situation, maybe I wouldn't have made this review! So no misunderstandings, just no communication on your end. Anyway, I do think it's extremely weird that you are looking me up on Instagram and getting so hung up on a 22 year old's opinion on your business. If you are so confident in how long you've been around and whatnot, why would you even give a damn about my review? And furthermore, why would you look me up? Honestly it makes sense because I failed to mention that your customers were WEIRD from the second we walked in. They were decades older than us hitting on my friends and I which was why we spent maybe 20 minutes tops there. Oh and also I never used the word traumatic. Unfortunately, I've been through much worse than what I had to deal with at your establishment so don't worry about me being traumatized. I will however take any photo of me that looks good and use it to my own advantage. I really don't give a damn where it was taken unfortunately. Especially since no one will ever know it was taken there except you, someone who has claimed they are much older than me while looking up my Instagram. And finally, no of course I did not get my degree in marine biology. And I'm assuming you didn't either. Which should make it all the more scary for your fish to look this bad. Several other customers also noted the obvious health status of the fish, whom I also assume are not marine biologists. But one little thing you didn't dive deep enough into my Instagram to find out was the fact that I am an exotic pet owner! I've been spending time around exotic veterinarians for years and I've even co-parented a fish for a few years. But even without my experience, I think it's pretty obvious that a fish floating with its head up is actually not normal. It might be a symptom of swim bladder disorder, which is a result of poor husbandry. But hey, maybe you've got all the experts you need, so my apologies for overstepping. I can see my language in my initial review triggered a response from you and your staff, and for that I am sorry. But seriously if you have been in this industry for so long and you are sooooo much older than me.... maybe don't take every review to heart LOL. I am literally a 22 year old girl, pipe down. Anyways thanks and I wish you all the best business ventures!
